Recently, a post was shared on X by ICAR (Indian Council of Agricultural Research), praising the GI (Geographical Indication) tag awarded to Bihar's famous 'Magahi Paan' and the benefits it brings to farmers. However, if we look at the 'dark side' and the ground reality of this story, this glitter is not as straightforward as it seems.
Beyond government advertisements and claims, if a deep analysis of this entire value chain is done with facts and numbers, the truth is indeed serious:
The Game of Middlemen: Is the benefit of increased prices directly reaching small farmers?
The answer is—absolutely not! The government report claims that after the formation of the FPC (Farmer Producer Company), the price of Magahi Paan has increased from ₹120-₹140 per dholi (200 leaves) to ₹280-₹300 per dholi. But the reality is different:
The Syndicate of Wholesalers in Markets: Small farmers of Nawada and Nalanda still cannot send their paan directly to big markets in Mumbai or Delhi. They have to sell their produce only to the traditional big wholesalers (middlemen) of Banaras and Gaya. In the off-season, these middlemen give advance loans to poor farmers to build the bareja (shed). In exchange for this loan, when the season arrives, they book the entire paan from the farmers at very low rates in advance. The result is that even if the price in the market reaches ₹300 per dholi, the farmer still gets the same old pre-fixed meager price. The entire profit is made by the middleman.
Global Export Scenario
Demand Among Diaspora vs Zero Cold-Chain Infrastructure: A quiet demand for Magahi Paan always remains among the Indian diaspora living in the UK, USA, Canada, Middle East, Malaysia, and Singapore. Along with this, it has huge potential in ayurvedic extracts and herbal antiseptics due to its pharmaceutical-grade essential oil (1-3% eugenol-rich oil). But the problem is that Magahi Paan leaves are highly delicate and perishable. If they are not kept at the right temperature within 48 to 72 hours after harvesting, they turn black. Cold-chain infrastructure (refrigerated vans, pre-cooling units) is almost completely absent in these producing districts of Bihar.
Sharp Decline in Exports: At one time, when the total betel leaf exports from India were at a respectable level of ~10,000 metric tons (MT), it has now shrunk to a very small amount globally due to phytosanitary (microbial) reasons and strict regulations.
Negligible Share in Bihar's Total Exports: If we talk about the state's total export basket, the share of Magahi Paan in Bihar's total exports is currently only around 0.48%, which proves that even 8 years after getting the GI tag, it has not been able to get any major international market access.
Rapidly Declining Farmer Base
More than 60% Farmers Abandoned Farming: During 2013-15, around 8,000 farmers were associated with the traditional cultivation of Magahi Paan in Bihar. But according to current recent reports and ground surveys, this number has rapidly decreased to 3,000 or even fewer. Traditional families of the Chaurasia community are now giving up this work. On the other hand, the new generation (youth) is running completely away from this farming. The biggest reason for this is the rising cost—the cost of bamboo, straw, and mesh to make the bareja (bhittha/shed) has doubled in the last 5 years. On top of that, wages have crossed ₹300/day. Since the farming requires 14 hours of hard physical labor and the profit remains completely uncertain, youth find it better to work as laborers in cities.
The Most Crucial Impact of Climate Change: Magahi Paan cultivation takes place inside the bhittha under a controlled humidity. In the past few years, due to the extreme heatwaves and sudden unseasonal heavy rains in Bihar, the temperature inside the bhittha gets disturbed, causing the entire crop to rot overnight. Looking at the land records of many traditional villages makes one shudder. In villages where paan barejas used to thrive in 40-40 bighas earlier, now only 1 to 2 bighas of cultivation is left. Crop insurance from the government is next to nothing.
Production Hardships & Competition
Varieties like Calcutta, Desi, and Bangla paan in the market are much cheaper and very easy to grow compared to Magahi Paan. The vines of Calcutta or Bangla paan give leaves continuously for 15 to 20 years once planted in the ground. Completely opposite to this, the nature of Magahi Paan is such that it has to be uprooted every year, the entire land has to be cleared, and a new plantation has to be done. This means the same heavy cost and the same bone-breaking labor from the beginning every year.
The Result: The common buyer or the commercial zarda/gutkha industry in the market is rapidly adopting these cheap and durable options instead of Magahi Paan, due to which the market for Magahi Paan is constantly shrinking.
Public Health vs Livelihood Conflict
A Big Cause of Cancer: The paan leaf in itself can be medicinal, but its main consumption in India is with betel nut, catechu (kattha), lime, and mainly tobacco/zarda, which is considered the biggest cause of oral cancer.
Strict Stance of Governments: WHO (World Health Organization) and India's Central Health Ministry both completely discourage its consumption. Due to campaigns against cancer, there is a legal ban on its direct promotion or branding.
International Ban and Strict Restrictions: Due to this health risk and sanitation standards (like the risk of Salmonella bacteria), strict restrictions or a total ban (restrictions/ban) are in place on the commercial import of paan in countries like the UAE, Qatar, and Singapore.
Future Collapse (A Classic Conflict): Due to rising health awareness in the new generation, a sharp decline in the chewing habit of paan is certain in the coming times. This is the biggest and bitterest contradiction of this industry—on one side is the livelihood of thousands of poor farmers, and on the other side is the big issue of public health.
The truth is that this ICAR advertisement claiming that 1,001 farmers have been organized is like putting a small band-aid on a huge mountain of crisis. Until the government:
- Breaks the syndicate of middlemen and gives direct market linkage to the farmers,
- Builds cold-chain corridors to airports for exports,
- And re-brands it for its ayurvedic and essential oil extraction instead of harmful chewing paan and sets up factories,
Until then, this 'Magahi Paan', called the pride of Bihar's culture, will remain buried in government files merely as a GI tag certificate.
References:
0 Comments