Delhi’s Air Quality Index (AQI) has been hovering in the Severe and often touching the Severe Plus category, with recent averages between 387–416 and at times crossing 450. At these levels, breathing itself becomes difficult, and the health risks for children, the elderly, and those with respiratory conditions rise sharply.
Whenever the AQI breaches 450, the government enforces Stage IV of the Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP‑IV) — the strictest emergency pollution‑control measure for Delhi‑NCR. This stage bans all non‑essential construction and demolition, restricts polluting vehicles, and temporarily shuts down industries. These steps are vital to protect public health and reduce toxic smog.
Yet behind these emergency measures lies a hidden social cost. While pollution‑control bans may provide relief to the environment, they suddenly snatch away the livelihoods of millions of workers. The immediate victims are not policymakers or corporations, but the daily‑wage labourers whose income vanishes overnight. Construction workers, factory hands, and transport workers depend on daily wages to feed their families. When sites are shut down, their earnings stop instantly, making survival — food, rent, medicines — nearly impossible.
The construction sector is one of the largest employers in India. In Delhi alone, millions of registered and unregistered workers are affected, and when GRAP‑IV is implemented, their income becomes zero overnight. The truth is that the hidden victims of pollution‑control steps are labourers. This is Delhi’s policy dilemma: pollution bans save lives, but they simultaneously push informal workers into poverty and hunger. Policymakers look at AQI numbers, but on the ground, a worker struggles to feed his children.
Media reports and ground‑level studies confirm that these workers face immense difficulty in meeting their basic needs — food, rent, medicines — because they have no savings or social security cover.
Impact of Pollution-Control Bans on Labour Livelihoods
When pollution-control restrictions, such as the Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP), are enforced, the daily earnings of ₹700 to ₹800 for workers in construction, factories, and transport instantly halt. This sudden and complete loss of income plunges these daily-wage laborers, who typically lack savings or a strong social safety net, into an immediate cash crisis. This financial shock makes it impossible to cover basic needs like rent, food, and essentials for their families, directly and severely escalating the risk of poverty, hunger, and destitution.
For example, in Delhi-NCR, every year lakhs of construction and factory workers lose their livelihoods directly due to bans, while across India crores of informal workers are indirectly affected. This is a hidden social cost that is often ignored in policy debates and parliamentary sessions.
1. Delhi-NCR: Loss of Livelihoods
| Region | Sector affected | Estimated labour impact |
|---|---|---|
| Delhi NCR | Construction, factories | ~10–12 lakh workers annually face income loss |
| North India | Brick kilns, transport, stubble burning bans | Lakhs of seasonal workers affected |
| India-wide | Informal sector (90% workforce) | Crores indirectly impacted during bans |
2. Nationwide Impact on Informal Workers
Seasonal bans across different states affect crores of informal workers. India’s workforce is 80–90% informal, covering construction, small-scale manufacturing, and transport. Whenever pollution, floods, or other emergencies halt large-scale economic activity, millions of informal workers lose their livelihoods directly.
3. Policy Dilemma
Pollution bans create a major policy dilemma: while they protect public health and reduce pollution levels, they simultaneously push informal workers into poverty and hunger. With no savings or social safety net, even a few days of lost work can destabilize their lives.
4. Systemic Flaws in Compensation: The Registration Barrier
While compensation schemes (like the ₹8,000 allowance) are announced, the actual disbursement is severely limited by systemic flaws in the registration process for the Building and Other Construction Workers (BOCW) Welfare Boards. These flaws effectively exclude the majority of the workforce:
- Migrant Status and Documentation: The majority of Delhi-NCR's construction workers are inter-state migrants (from UP, Bihar, etc.) who lack the necessary permanent address proof, local utility bills, or stable tenancy agreements required for registration.
- The 90-Day Rule: To be eligible, a worker must provide proof of working at least 90 days in the preceding 12 months. Since most informal construction work is project-based and short-term, employers (contractors) are often unwilling or unable to provide the required official employment certificate, immediately excluding millions of workers.
- Low Awareness and Cumbersome Process: Workers often lack awareness of the schemes, and the registration process itself is highly bureaucratic, requiring multiple visits, documents, and renewals. This is nearly impossible for daily wage earners who cannot afford to lose a day's pay to visit a government office.
- Registration Renewal: Even among those registered, many memberships expire because annual renewal is mandatory but often neglected due to the bureaucratic hurdles and lack of proactive outreach. Workers with expired cards cannot receive compensation.
The Result: Only a fraction of the estimated workers (often less than 10-15%) are "active" and eligible members, leaving the vast majority of those who lose their livelihoods during a GRAP ban without any financial safety net.
Hidden Social Fallout of Pollution Bans
Ground-level reporting and criminology studies show that during sudden unemployment, migrant and daily-wage workers often turn to petty crime, illegal liquor trade, scrap theft, or unsafe informal jobs. This is a hidden social fallout that is rarely acknowledged. Economically, it reflects the concept of “Necessity Crime” — when individuals cross legal boundaries to meet basic survival needs.
Unreported Struggles: Many workers are forced into hazardous informal jobs, such as handling chemicals or waste without safety measures, which pose serious health risks.
- Migration Pressure: When bans are imposed in NCR and other major cities, workers return to their villages, but the lack of employment there leads to unsafe migration and further instability for their families.
- Crime Link: Studies indicate that sudden loss of livelihood increases petty crime, including theft, illegal liquor trade, and small-scale smuggling. Though rarely acknowledged, this remains a ground reality.
| Activity Type | Description | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Petty Crime | Stealing or snatching small items that can quickly be converted into cash. | Stealing essential goods (food), snatching small valuables in public. |
| Scrap/Property Theft | Stealing materials that are easily sold to junk dealers (scrap yards). | Stealing iron, copper, or metal scrap from construction sites or closed factories. |
| Illegal Trade | Engaging in the sale of prohibited or illicitly produced goods for high profit. | Brewing or trading illegal liquor, small-scale trafficking of contraband. |
| Unsafe/Exploitative Labor | Accepting extremely hazardous and low-wage jobs out of desperation. | Cleaning sewers/drains without safety gear, taking up high-risk work in illegal factories. |
Social Fabric Risk: The crisis is not only economic but also social. When survival itself becomes uncertain, moral boundaries weaken, creating deeper instability in society.
Unfortunately, no major political party or public institution has seriously addressed how to safeguard workers’ livelihoods during pollution-control bans.
Mental Impact and What Could Be Done
GRAP-IV restrictions not only halt economic activity but also trigger a hidden mental health crisis among daily-wage workers. The sudden loss of income pushes many into hunger and debt, intensifying stress, anxiety, and hopelessness. Workers like Suman and Babu Ram, as reported by Devdiscourse, were unable to support their families during these bans and slipped into depression. Unemployment creates a sense of social insecurity, as workers feel neglected by society and government, while the guilt of not being able to provide food, rent, or medicines for their families further erodes their self-esteem. This psychological pressure weakens workers and destabilizes both their families and the broader social fabric.
To address this overlooked dimension of pollution control, governments must integrate livelihood protection into emergency measures.
1. Implement an Urban Employment Guarantee Scheme (Urban-EGS)
The most critical step is adapting the MNREGA model for cities. An Urban Employment Guarantee Scheme (Urban-EGS) would guarantee a minimum number of days of work for all registered urban informal workers.
- Alternative Work Pool: During construction bans, this scheme would activate to offer "Green Jobs" that assist with local pollution mitigation, such as large-scale road sweeping, water sprinkling for dust control, setting up dust screens/barriers, and maintenance of public spaces.
- Benefit: This provides displaced workers with immediate, dignified wages, converting unemployment and psychological distress into positive community action.
2. Reform and Mobilize the BOCW Cess Fund
The existing Building and Other Construction Workers' (BOCW) Cess Fund must be fully utilized for rapid relief.
- Immediate Financial Relief: The BOCW cess fund should be mobilized to provide the promised temporary allowances (like the ₹8,000) within 48 hours of a GRAP-IV notification.
- Registration Overhaul: The process must be simplified by accepting common documents and allowing Self-Certification or certification by trade unions to overcome the documentation and migrant-status barriers. Proactive mobile registration camps near work sites are essential.
3. Establish a contingency safety net (basic income)
For all other informal workers (outside the BOCW structure) indirectly affected, a contingency fund must provide support.
Mechanism: Leverage the existing Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) infrastructure to provide a small, rapid emergency Basic Income Transfer to all workers registered on national databases (like the e-Shram portal) during mandated shutdowns.
By securing the economic lifeline of the labour class, these policies can mitigate the severe mental health crisis and social instability triggered by necessary environmental protection measures.
0 Comments